California · Disputes

California HOA internal dispute resolution: what Civil Code 5900 to 5920 require

7 min read · Last reviewed · For volunteer boards

In this guide

Key points

  • Under the Davis-Stirling Act, a California association must provide a fair, reasonable and expeditious procedure for resolving a dispute with a member. Sections 5900 to 5920 call it internal dispute resolution, or IDR.
  • Section 5910 sets the minimum: either side can start it in writing, the board must take part when a member does, there are prompt deadlines, and the member pays no fee.
  • If the association has no procedure of its own, the meet and confer steps in § 5915 apply. A member may refuse to meet. The association may not.
  • This is a plain-language guide to current statute text, not legal advice. Your attorney decides how it applies to your documents.

Not legal advice. This page is general information for volunteer boards. It is not legal advice, and laws and documents differ. Ask your association’s attorney before you act on it.

Which disputes it covers

The article applies to a dispute between the association and a member about their rights, duties or liabilities. The source can be the Davis-Stirling Act, the Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law, or your governing documents.

Section 5900 says this article adds to the separate rules on alternative dispute resolution before an enforcement action. This guide covers IDR only.

“This article applies to a dispute between an association and a member involving their rights, duties, or liabilities under this act, under the Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law (Part 3 (commencing with Section 7110) of Division 2 of Title 1 of the Corporations Code), or under the governing documents of the common interest development or association.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5900(a)

The duty to offer a fair procedure

The association must have a procedure that is fair, reasonable and expeditious. In building it, the statute tells the association to make maximum, reasonable use of local programs that bring in a neutral third party, such as low-cost mediation.

If the association does not provide a procedure that meets the standard, the statute supplies one. The meet and confer steps in § 5915 then apply, and they count as meeting the requirement.

“An association shall provide a fair, reasonable, and expeditious procedure for resolving a dispute within the scope of this article.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5905(a)

The minimum a procedure must have

Section 5910 lists what any IDR procedure must satisfy. You can offer more than this. You cannot offer less.

Two points trip up small boards. The procedure must state the maximum time the association has to act on a request, so the written policy needs a number. And the member pays nothing to take part.

“A fair, reasonable, and expeditious dispute resolution procedure shall, at a minimum, satisfy all of the following requirements:”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5910
“The procedure may be invoked by either party to the dispute. A request invoking the procedure shall be in writing.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5910(a)
“The procedure shall provide for prompt deadlines. The procedure shall state the maximum time for the association to act on a request invoking the procedure.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5910(b)
“A member of the association shall not be charged a fee to participate in the process.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5910(g)

Who can start it, and who has to show up

Either side can invoke the procedure, but the consequences differ. If a member invokes it, the association must take part. If the association invokes it, the member may decline. A member who does take part and loses has a right of appeal to the board.

“If the procedure is invoked by a member, the association shall participate in the procedure.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5910(c)
“If the procedure is invoked by the association, the member may elect not to participate in the procedure. If the member participates but the dispute is resolved other than by agreement of the member, the member shall have a right of appeal to the board.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5910(d)

A signed resolution binds

A signed written resolution that does not conflict with the law or the governing documents binds the association and can be enforced in court. Read any proposed settlement against the documents before the board signs.

“A written resolution, signed by both parties, of a dispute pursuant to the procedure that is not in conflict with the law or the governing documents binds the association and is judicially enforceable. A written agreement, signed by both parties, reached pursuant to the procedure that is not in conflict with the law or the governing documents binds the parties and is judicially enforceable.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5910(e)

The fallback: meet and confer

Section 5915 applies to an association that does not otherwise provide a fair procedure. Either side may ask the other to meet and confer, in writing. The asymmetry is deliberate: a member can say no, the association cannot.

The board names one director to meet with the member. The two sides meet promptly, at a time and place that suits both, explain their positions and try in good faith to settle. A settlement is written down and signed by the member and the board’s designee.

“The party may request the other party to meet and confer in an effort to resolve the dispute. The request shall be in writing.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5915(b)(1)
“A member of an association may refuse a request to meet and confer. The association shall not refuse a request to meet and confer.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5915(b)(2)
“The board shall designate a director to meet and confer.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5915(b)(3)
“A resolution of the dispute agreed to by the parties shall be memorialized in writing and signed by the parties, including the board designee on behalf of the association.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5915(b)(5)

When a meet and confer agreement binds the board

An agreement reached this way is enforceable if both sides sign it, it does not conflict with the law or the documents, and it is either within the authority the board gave its designee or the board ratifies it. A director who goes beyond the board’s instructions should say the agreement needs ratification.

“A written agreement reached under this section binds the parties and is judicially enforceable if it is signed by both parties and both of the following conditions are satisfied:”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5915(c)

Tell members about it every year

The annual policy statement must describe the IDR process. If yours does not, add it at the next mailing. The same statement carries the fine schedule, so the two are usually updated together.

“The annual policy statement prepared pursuant to Section 5310 shall include a description of the internal dispute resolution process provided pursuant to this article.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5920

Where it meets a fine hearing

Section 5855(d) says that when the board and the member do not agree after a discipline hearing, the member can ask for IDR under § 5910. Our guide to California fines and hearings covers the rest of that process.

“If the board and the member are not in agreement after the meeting, a member shall have the opportunity to request internal dispute resolution pursuant to Section 5910.”
Cal. Civ. Code § 5855(d)

What this page does not tell you

We hold the text of §§ 5900 to 5920 and the surrounding sections of the Act. We cannot tell you what your governing documents add or whether your current procedure meets § 5910. Have your attorney read it once.

What to do next

  1. 1Find your current IDR description in the annual policy statement. If there is none, that is the first gap to fix.
  2. 2Write the procedure: how a request is made in writing, who receives it, and the maximum time the board has to act.
  3. 3Check it against the § 5910 list, including the no-fee rule and the member’s right to decline when the association invokes it.
  4. 4Decide which director meets with members, and what authority the board gives that director to settle.
  5. 5Have your attorney review the procedure, then adopt it by board resolution.
  6. 6Describe it in the next annual policy statement.
  7. 7When a request arrives, log the date, answer within the stated time, and keep the signed outcome on file.

What HomeownerHub does about this

  • In California, the fine and suspension letters mention the 14-day written decision and the owner’s right to ask for internal dispute resolution under § 5910 after a disputed hearing.
  • In California, a violation can only move to Fined once the hearing record shows the notice sent in time, the hearing held, and the outcome recorded. "Attorney advised" is the only override, and it is recorded.

The board approves every draft. HomeownerHub prepares paperwork and cites the law; it does not file for you or give legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is internal dispute resolution in a California HOA?
It is the association’s own procedure for settling a dispute with a member, required by Civil Code §§ 5900 to 5920. It must be fair, reasonable and expeditious, and it must meet the minimums in § 5910.
Can a member refuse to take part?
Yes, when the association is the one that invokes the procedure. If the member invokes it, the association must take part. Under the meet and confer fallback, a member may refuse a request and the association may not.
Can the association charge a fee for IDR?
No. Both § 5910 and § 5915 say a member shall not be charged a fee to participate.
What if our association has no written IDR procedure?
The statute says the § 5915 meet and confer procedure applies and satisfies the requirement. The annual policy statement should still describe the process the association uses.

Want this handled for your board?

Book a short demo. We load your governing documents and show the tools on your own rules. The board decides afterwards. We reply within 1 business day.

90-day free trial, one-time $99 setup and onboarding fee · Not legal advice